Grateful Dead: "Dave's Picks Bonus Disc 2026" (2026) CD Review

Thanks to my mom, I have a subscription to the Dave's Picks series of Grateful Dead concert releases. Four times a year, a new Grateful Dead show arrives in my mail box (or somewhere in the general vicinity of my mail box, as happened with the new volume), and once a year that show is accompanied by a bonus disc. This year the bonus disc arrived with Dave's Picks Volume 58, a three-disc set that contains the complete show the Dead played on December 18, 1973, and a couple of songs from the December 12, 1973 show too. The Dave's Picks Bonus Disc 2026 contains more songs from that December 12th show at The Omni in Atlanta, Georgia, songs from both the first set and second set.

The disc opens with "Sugaree," which was the second song of the first set, following "Promised Land." Interestingly, some setlists online don't include the first four songs of the show, perhaps basing their list on incomplete audience tapes. Anyway, this is a sweet rendition of "Sugaree," featuring a vocal performance from Jerry Garcia that is wonderfully gentle at the beginning. This song grows in power at the right moments, a song of hills and valleys, and of beauty. The disc then skips to the middle of the first set for "Peggy-O," this being only the second time the band played this song. The first was two days earlier. And again, Jerry's voice is so gentle, so sweet as the song begins. And the track features some really nice work by Keith Godchaux on keys. There is something about this rendition that just feels so good. Then we go to the final song of the first set, a glorious, epic "Playing In The Band." It begins with that wonderful energy, like something opening, like a bright light breaking over us, and then gets into the action of the main theme of the song. But of course the real action is after that, when the band begins to explore other spaces, when the music takes us away from the ground, away from stage, almost like the music somehow separates from the instruments, taking on its own life and choosing its own direction. There is a moment, approximately six minutes thirty-eight seconds in, when the sound shifts to a lesser source. There were a few of those moments on the discs of Volume 58 too. It lasts nearly a minute, and then we are back to the clearer, crisper sound. By that point, it is like the entire universe is dancing, everything the music encounters becoming immersed in the groove, in the energy, in the drive outward. Bill Kreutzman's drumming is so good, and Jerry's guitar reaches to delicious heights, and sometimes turns inward too. What I love is that this version is able to get out there into those exciting places while still maintaining, more or less, a wonderful rhythm that we can hold onto. And then, somewhere around the nineteen-minute mark, the song's main theme is re-established. I always love when the song kicks back into that theme with full force. It's like a welcome back to the earth, but now with whatever knowledge and experience we've gathered along the way, and so our approach to the song is different. There is often more joy. We are not quite the same people we were when this started.

We then skip the first couple of songs of the second set and go right to "China Cat Sunflower," and so we head straight back into interesting territory. After all, there was never any question about what this song was about. Here the structure remains even more intact, while still giving us a chance to open up to different realms. The jam here moves forward with a joyful, delicious force, certain of itself, of its destination. And soon we are into "I Know You Rider," which begins in perhaps a somewhat mellow place, yet with a good amount of heart, and then rises to a great peak on Jerry's "I wish I was a headlight on a northbound train." The disc skips a couple of songs, and moves to "Weather Report Suite," the full song, including the pretty, meditative "Prelude" and a really nice rendition of "Part 1," even if Bob Weir seems to momentarily lose his place. This song feels like it can take care of us, can see us through. "We'll see summer by and by." And then we're into the "Let It Grow" part, the only section that I ever got to see the Dead perform. There is a wonderful power to this piece, and we get a strong rendition here. "And listen to the thunder shout, I am! I am!" What an excellent jam, showing again how 1973 was the best year for the band, as far as live performances are concerned. The band then goes into "Wharf Rat," another of my personal favorites. And this is a striking rendition. Listen to the ache and determination in Jerry's voice as he sings, "But I'll get back on my feet someday." The song at key moments feels like a combination of magic and perseverance. And it gently lets us go at the end.

CD Track List

1. Sugaree
2. Peggy-O
3. Playing In The Band
4. China Cat Sunflower >
5. I Know You Rider
6. Weather Report Suite
7. Wharf Rat

Dave's Picks Bonus Disc 2026 was released in early May, 2026.