 |
| The Baseball Project (photo by Tim Doherty) |
The Baseball Project and The Minus 5 are currently touring together, a fantastic double bill, which they are describing as a doubleheader. This makes perfect sense, for in addition to being a wonderfully playful reference to a baseball term, the lineup of both bands for this tour is the same. While both bands normally share a few musicians, this time around all five members of The Baseball Project are The Minus 5 too. The bands brought this incredible doubleheader action to the Boston area last night, while the Red Sox are fighting for a playoff spot. That playoff spot looks like the second or third wild card. Having more than one wild card is absurd - can you imagine a professional poker game with three wild cards? - but for folks in Boston, it's important for the team to have a chance, however ridiculous the way in may be. And so there was that great September baseball energy in the city. What better atmosphere for The Baseball Project to play in?
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
Leading off the night was The Minus 5, a band celebrating the release of its phenomenal new album,
Oar On, Penelope!, and now including, on the album if not on the tour, Debbi Peterson (whom you know from The Bangles) as a member. For those who aren't familiar with the band, it was started by Scott McCaughey (of The Young Fresh Fellows and also known for his work with R.E.M.), along with Peter Buck (of R.E.M.), both of whom are also members of The Baseball Project. And though the players last night were the same as in The Baseball Project, there was a different batting order for this set, with Peter Buck on bass, positioned stage left, while Mike Mills was on keyboard, stage right. At 8:09 p.m., Scott led the band onto the stage, sporting a Minus 5 "Oar On" T-shirt. "
We're going to sing eleven songs not about baseball," he told the crowd, promising a good rock set and saying that after that it would be all baseball for the rest of the night. The Minus 5 then got right into it with "Words & Birds," the lead track from the new album, and followed it with another song from
Oar On, "The Garden Of Arden." "
Here's an old song," Scott said, and the band launched into "You Don't Mean It" from the album
Let The War Against Music Begin. That was followed by an excellent and energetic rendition of "Falling Like Jets," another song from the new album.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
Josh Kantor had been spotted in the crowd before the show, and he now joined the band on stage, playing accordion. He's been playing with some fantastic artists. Last fall, he did a short tour with Jon Langford and Sally Timms of The Mekons. Of course, Boston baseball fans know him as the organist at Fenway Park. And we love him for his work in Jim's Big Ego, Jim Infantino's band. And though he lives in Boston, he grew up in Athens, Georgia (you know, the place where R.E.M. came from), and has been connected with The Baseball Project for a while. The first song he joined them on was a cover of Buffalo Springfield's "Out Of My Mind," a good choice for these strange days. That was followed by "I Don't Want To Hate Anyone," a particularly good track from the new album, with Peter leading the band into it on bass, and Steve Wynn delivering some excellent stuff on guitar. Josh then left the stage, and Casey Neill joined the band on guitar and backing vocals for the rest of the set.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
From the band's 2006 self-titled album, they played "Twilight Distillery." mentioning that this was the first time they'd played the song on this tour. The song featured some really strong vocal work, and at the end, Scott gleefully exclaimed, "
Sweet!" Indeed! It was certainly one of the set's highlights, and it was followed by another highlight, "Let The Rope Hold, Cassie Lee," a song from the new album. While introducing the song, Scott mentioned how the new album features a pretty girl on the front cover and a pretty dog on the back cover. "
Don't get them confused," Mike joked. This was an incredibly fun rendition, with Steve at the edge of the stage rocking the guitar, and Scott jumping around. They followed that with a cover of "She Cracked" by The Modern Lovers, a band that is of course held in particularly high regard in Boston. The band delivered a really good take on that song. That was followed by "In The Ground," a song that was included on the
Dungeon Golds disc. They then wrapped up the set with a great rendition of Neil Young's "Hitchhiker," a song that The Minus 5 recorded for
Calling Cortez. It was a great rock and roll set, just as Scott had promised at the beginning. The set ended at 8:49 p.m.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
At 9:12 p.m., the band was back on stage, now as The Baseball Project, with Peter Buck on guitar, stage right, and Mike Mills on bass, stage left. Scott no longer had on his Minus 5 shirt, and was now sporting a striped shirt. There was no introduction, the band immediately ripping into the first number, "1976." the lead track from the band's
Volume 2: High And Inside. For those who might not yet be aware of this band, it is made up of serious baseball fans, and all of the material they perform and record is related to baseball. All of it. And it's fantastic. For example, that first song "1976" is about a player named Mark Fidrych, who was a rookie in 1976, the lyrics likening him to Peter Frampton, whose
Frampton Comes Alive album came out that year. This song featured Steve Wynn on lead vocals, and Peter Buck on twelve-string guitar. That player, by the way, was born in Massachusetts, so a good choice to lead off this Boston show. Mike then asked the lighting technician to kill the white lights on the stage. Any other color is fine, he said. Two seconds later the stage had more blue on it. From a song about Mark "The Bird" Fidrych, they went to a song about Hank Aaron, "They Don't Know Henry," with Scott McCaughey on lead vocals, and Steve and Mike sharing a vocal microphone for the backing vocals.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
Peter switched to a six-string guitar for the title track to the band's most recent album,
Grand Salami Time, Scott on lead vocals for this one too. It's a fun song with a great energy, just what you'd expect for its subject. That was the first of several songs the band played from the latest album, following it with "Uncle Charlie," a song about the curve ball. Steve Wynn, who sings lead on this one, joked about how there have been many great songs written about the curve ball, such as "Bridge Over Troubled Curve Balls." Steve then introduced "The Yips" as "
a song all about fucking up." It's one of my favorites from the album, and they followed it with another of that disc's standout tracks, "Stuff." Mike introduced it by talking about going to spring training and learning that seventy-five to eighty percent of pitchers put stuff on the ball. I love the darker vibe of this song. Some people in the audience cheered after the line about Vaseline.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
"
Here's a song about a guy you might know," Steve said, introducing "Ted Fucking Williams." My brother and I had been in the front row at the beginning of the set, but the sound wasn't great there. It was mostly guitar, with the vocals suffering by comparison. So we had moved a bit farther back after the first four songs, and I ended up behind a guy wearing a Ted Williams jersey. I figured he'd go nuts for that song, but I guess he was a bit more reserved than we were. Still, the audience was singing along. How could you refrain from singing, or shouting, along to this one, especially in Massachusetts? This song was a whole hell of a lot of fun. And speaking of Boston baseball, Josh Kantor then joined the band on accordion for the next couple of songs, first updating the crowd on the scores of the Red Sox and Yankees games. Fittingly, the next song was "Box Scores," with Scott on lead vocals, and Peter back on the twelve-string. Josh got a chance to lead for a moment. I just love that they have a song dedicated to box scores, something we'd study as kids, taking as much information as we could and imagining the games from the night before based on that information. After that song, Steve called Josh the "
Cal Ripken of organists," since Josh hadn't missed a game. That song was followed by "Twilight Of My Career," which has its own Boston connection, being about Roger Clemens, though focusing on his career after leaving the Red Sox. Josh then left the stage, and right about then Peter told his band mates, "
It's twelve-string from here on out." There was some issue with his other guitar.
 |
| photo by Tim Doherty |
The band then returned to material from
Grand Salami Time, delivering a great rendition of "New Oh In Town," a song about Shohei Ohtani and one that is a lot of fun to sing along with, and following it with "Journeyman," a song written by Steve Wynn and Peter Buck. It's kind of a sad song, with lines like "
Always keep my bags packed/Never get too close to anyone," but I was dancing to it anyway. It was that kind of night, when the energy and the joy kept our bodies moving, kept us smiling. This band creates a fun atmosphere, especially when delivering songs like "From Nails To Thumbtacks" and "Disco Demolition." The first of those two is about Lenny Dykstra, who had been on the Mets in the 1986 World Series, a series that haunted Boston until 2004. It's a great rock and roll number, even including a section of vocals and drums. I've always had a weakness for such things. Linda Pitmon's drumming is so damn good ("
Yo, Pitmon!"), and then during "Disco Demolition," she was also blowing the whistle. That song is about a specific game and a promotional gimmick that went all sorts of wrong. That game, the first of what was scheduled to be a doubleheader on July 12, 1979, and everything that resulted, can be viewed online, and I recommend checking it out. Peter was back on the six-string for this song, but soon went back to the twelve-string.
Each baseball fan has at least one player that he or she fervently believes should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame. For Mike Mills, that player is Dale Murphy, and that's what the song "To The Veterans Committee" is about. Have the people on the committee not heard this song yet? Come on, guys! The song has convinced me he deserves a spot in the Hall of Fame. Steve then told the Boston crowd that he thought it was time to sing about a Yankee. That was, predictably and understandably, met with some jeers from the crowd, but all in good fun. The song, "Monument Park," is about Bernie Williams. Even for those of us who hate the Yankees, it's pretty difficult to hate Bernie Williams. Same goes for a guy like Scott Brosius. They don't deserve any hatred. Save that for pricks like Jorge Posada and Alex Rodriguez. Linda then counted off "Past Time," a song that featured a great scream from Scott. They wrapped up the set with "¡Hola America!" which featured some excellent stuff from Linda on drums.
Moments later the band was back on stage for the encore. "
Thank you, Boston," Mike said to the crowd. He then said they saw the new
Spinal Tap movie, and found it disturbing, joking how weird it is for people to get old and still play in bands. They started the encore with "Ichiro Goes To The Moon," a wonderful song from
Volume 2: High And Inside. Steve Wynn then mentioned that The Dream Syndicate will be coming to town in December. (And I learned they'll be in Los Angeles in November, so I need to get a ticket for that one.) Josh Kantor joined the band for "Harvey Haddix," which was perhaps the most fun song of the entire night. Josh exited the stage, and Scott announced: "
This is our last song. I hope you like it. It's a great one." That song, "The All Or Nothings," is a great hard-rocking number from
Grand Salami Time, a delicious way to wrap things up. The show ended at 10:36 p.m., but the night was not quite over, for the band soon came out to chat with folks and sign records and CDs and whatever else people might have bought or brought.
The Minus 5 Set List
- Words & Birds
- The Garden Of Arden
- You Don't Mean It
- Falling Like Jets
- Out Of My Mind
- I Don't Want To Hate Anyone
- Twilight Distillery
- Let The Rope Hold, Cassie Lee
- She Cracked
- In The Ground
- Hitchhiker
The Baseball Project Set List- 1976
- They Don't Know Henry
- Grand Salami Time
- Uncle Charlie
- The Yips
- Stuff
- Ted Fucking Williams
- Box Scores
- Twilight Of My Career
- New Oh In Town
- Journeyman
- From Nails To Thumbtacks
- Disco Demolition
- To The Veterans Committee
- Monument Park
- Past Time
- ¡Hola America!
Encore
- Ichiro Goes To The Moon
- Harvey Haddix
- The All Or Nothings
Crystal Ballroom is located at 55 Davis Square in Somerville, Massachusetts (attached to the Somerville Theatre).